https://www.polity.org.za
Deepening Democracy through Access to Information
Home / Opinion / Other Opinions RSS ← Back
Africa|Business|Financial|Power|Resources|Service
Africa|Business|Financial|Power|Resources|Service
africa|business|financial|power|resources|service
Close

Email this article

separate emails by commas, maximum limit of 4 addresses

Sponsored by

Close

Article Enquiry

Kenya's new finance minister has surprising numbers about public debt, loans, sugar demand and VAT

Close

Embed Video

Kenya's new finance minister has surprising numbers about public debt, loans, sugar demand and VAT

Africa Check

30th August 2024

By: Africa Check

SAVE THIS ARTICLE      EMAIL THIS ARTICLE

Font size: -+

Long-time opposition politician John Mbadi was appointed Kenya’s new finance minister on 7 August 2024. Before his appointment, Mbadi was a fierce critic of president William Ruto's administration's economic policies

With his appointment, he is expected to draw up new tax plans to increase government revenue. He has hinted at reintroducing some clauses from a hugely controversial finance bill that was scrapped, costing his predecessor his head.

Advertisement

On 22 August 2024, a fortnight after taking office, the critic-turned-insider was interviewed on Citizen TV, the country's most-watched television station, to explain his plans for the ailing economy. 

Mbadi spoke about the distressing public debt that is stifling government spending, the controversial relationship with the International Monetary Fund, and the new tax measures amid public calls for austerity. 

Advertisement

The minister made claims about public debt, interest rates on bilateral loans, his plans for the vital sugar industry and value added tax (VAT). We fact-checked his claims against the publicly available data.

Claim: “… if you look at our debt composition today, it's about fifty-fifty in terms of external and domestic debts.”

Verdict: Correct

External debt is money owed to foreign countries, multilateral institutions, and foreign creditors. Domestic debt is the debt owed to commercial banks, pension funds, businesses and individuals within a country. 

Mbadi said half the country’s debt was owed to foreign creditors and the other half to the domestic market.

Kenya’s national treasury publishes annual reports on the public debt. 

The most recent report, dated September 2023, showed that 52.9% of the public debt was external, and 47.1% was internal. 

The trend over five years shows an almost even split.

In addition, the treasury also publishes quarterly reports on the state of the economy. 

The most recent report, dated August 2024, showed an external debt of 48.8% and a domestic debt of 51.2%. 

It is not quite 50-50, but it is "about" right. Mbadi's claim is correct. – Alphonce Shiundu

Claim: “… when it comes to debt servicing cost, on domestic debt, you pay almost three times what you pay for the external debt.”

Verdict: Correct

Mbadi said Kenya was spending three times more on interest to its domestic creditors than to foreign creditors. “I am telling you clearly that our domestic debt is very expensive,” he said

The treasury's August 2024 quarterly report showed that in the financial year 2023/24, ending on 30 June 2024, the country spent KSh218.2-billion on external debt interest and KSh622.5-billion on domestic debt interest.

Mbadi was right that the government spent three times as much servicing domestic debt as it did on foreign debt. 

But there are also payments on the principal debt.

In the August 2024 report, a total of KSh756-billion was spent on external debt payments, of which KSh537.8-billion (71.1%) was spent on principal payments and KSh218.2-billion (28.9%) on interest.

Another treasury report on all government expenditure showed that KSh1.6-trillion was spent on public debt for 2023/24.

We know that KSh756-billion or 47.4% of the total debt expenditure was on external debt service, so we can infer that KSh840.6-billion or 52.6% was on domestic debt.

While the interest paid on domestic debt is three times higher than that paid on external debt, the split between total expenditure on the two types of debt nearly matches the debt shares. – Alphonce Shiundu

Claim: “... the Japanese government gives their loans at about 1%, 1.7%, 1.5% ...”

Verdict: Correct

To ease pressure on public funds, Mbadi said the country needed to reduce "expensive" domestic debt with high interest rates in favour of low-interest multilateral, concessional and bilateral loans with longer maturities.

“The Japanese government gives their loans at about 1%, 1.7%, 1.5% ...  so, even though it is bilateral, it is still cheaper,” the minister said

Africa Check asked Prof Hiroaki Shiga of the Graduate School of International Social Sciences at Japan’s Yokohama National University for the best source of data to assess this claim.

Shiga referred us to the Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA), the country’s global development agency. 

The data shows that Japan offers loans to countries at interest rates of between 0.4% and 2.4%. 

A summary is given below.

Japan's bilateral and multilateral lending rates

Country category

Interest rate

Examples of countries in this category

Low-income least developed country

0.4% 

Afghanistan, Rwanda, Ethiopia, Uganda, South Sudan

Low-income country or least-developed country

0.8% to 1.7%

Benin, Nepal, Senegal, Tanzania

Lower middle-income country

0.75% to 2.2%

Algeria, Cameroon, Ghana, India, Kenya, Morocco, Pakistan, Zimbabwe

Upper middle-income country and uppermost middle-income country

0.95% to 2.4%

Malaysia, Gabon, Mauritius, South Africa, Thailand, Turkey

Source: JICA, terms and conditions of Japanese ODA loans, effective 1 April 2024

We therefore rate this claim as accurate. –Tess Wandia

Claim: “I am not saying that the (sugar) demand has not been higher than the supply. It has been. We know that, and it has been there; those [are the] statistics.”

Verdict: Correct

Mbadi also said he was from the country's south-western sugar belt and wanted Kenya to be self-sufficient in sugar production. He said Kenya's sugar deficit has been persistent.

Sugar availability and pricing are politically volatile subjects in Kenya, where many state-owned sugar factories struggle to stay afloat. The high production costs make Kenyan sugar exports expensive, putting local sugarcane farmers at the mercy of cheap imports.

“I am not saying that the (sugar) demand has not been higher than the supply. It has been. We know that, and it has been there; those [are the] statistics,” he said.

Dr Timothy Njagi is a development economist and research fellow at the Tegemeo Institute, an agricultural thinktank. He referred us to the Agriculture and Food Authority (AFA).

Every year, the state agency publishes a yearbook of statistics containing detailed information on various crops, with a focus on agricultural production and market performance. 

Kenya’s statistics bureau also refers to the agriculture authority when reporting sugar production, imports and exports in its annual economic survey.

The authority’s 2024 statistical yearbook reported on the value of sugar imports and production from 2017 to 2023. In an email, Njagi also explained that in developing the balance sheet, the demand side includes production plus imports.

Year

Demand (production + imports)

(metric tonnes)

Supply (produced locally) (metric tonnes)

2017

376,111 + 989,619 = 1,365,730

376,111

2018

491,097 + 284,169 = 775,266

491,097

2019

440,935 + 458,631 = 899,566

440,935

2020

603,788 + 442,393 = 1,046,181

603,788

2021

700,241 + 426,334 = 1,126,575

700,241

2022

796,554 + 320,708 = 1,117,262

796,554

2023

472,773 + 608,178 = 1,080,951

472,773

Source: Agriculture and Food Authority, 2024

According to the data, demand for sugar has been significantly higher than supply for the past six years.

Mbadi’s claim checks out. – Tess Wandia

Claim: “On value-added tax, we are collecting only 3% of GDP ...”

Verdict: Understated

This report was written by Africa Check., a non-partisan fact-checking organisation. View the original piece on their website.

EMAIL THIS ARTICLE      SAVE THIS ARTICLE

To subscribe email subscriptions@creamermedia.co.za or click here
To advertise email advertising@creamermedia.co.za or click here

Comment Guidelines

About

Polity.org.za is a product of Creamer Media.
www.creamermedia.co.za

Other Creamer Media Products include:
Engineering News
Mining Weekly
Research Channel Africa

Read more

Subscriptions

We offer a variety of subscriptions to our Magazine, Website, PDF Reports and our photo library.

Subscriptions are available via the Creamer Media Store.

View store

Advertise

Advertising on Polity.org.za is an effective way to build and consolidate a company's profile among clients and prospective clients. Email advertising@creamermedia.co.za

View options

Email Registration Success

Thank you, you have successfully subscribed to one or more of Creamer Media’s email newsletters. You should start receiving the email newsletters in due course.

Our email newsletters may land in your junk or spam folder. To prevent this, kindly add newsletters@creamermedia.co.za to your address book or safe sender list. If you experience any issues with the receipt of our email newsletters, please email subscriptions@creamermedia.co.za