State says right-to-die ruling prejudices appeal

30th April 2015 By: RDM News Wire

State says right-to-die ruling prejudices appeal

Cape Town resident Robin Stransham-Ford can ask a doctor to help him die quietly in his bed with his former partner and young daughter with him.

Judge Hans Fabricius on Thursday morning ruled the doctor who helped him die or provided him with lethal drugs so he could help himself would not face criminal sanction or the threat of losing his medical licence from the Health Professions Council of SA.

He found Stransham-Ford to be mentally sound and facing a "severely curtailed life" as he expected to die from terminal prostate cancer within weeks or days.

He also said it was clear that Stransham-Ford had voluntarily approached the court and was under no duress from others to end his life.

Stransham-Ford approached the court last Tuesday with an urgent application that he be allowed to die as he found wasting away from cancer and being in pain "undignified".

He contended that his constitutional rights to dignity were being breached.

Fabricius ruled that the order only applied to Stransham-Ford and only the doctor who helped him would not be acting unlawfully‚ and no doctor was obliged to help him.

Other terminal patients would have to approach the courts themselves.

Fabricius’s order stated that the Constitutional rights to dignity as well as bodily and psychological integrity were at odds with the law that holds a doctor who helps with assisted suicide guilty of murder or culpable homicide.

Spokesperson for the justice department Mthunzi Mhaga said the state would appeal the ruling on Monday afternoon after the judge had issued his reasons for the order.

He said it was a "precedent-setting ruling that could open the floodgates for all other terminal patients who wanted assisted suicide to approach the courts" and the state was "extremely disappointed" by it.

He complained that the court was curtailing the director of public prosecutions from charging a doctor who gave Stransham-Ford a lethal injection with murder.

Although Fabricius will only give the reasons for his ruling on Monday‚ he made it clear that his ruling did not make the draft law on euthanasia‚ developed in 1998 by the Law Reform Commission‚ legal.

That law was presented to then-health Minister Manto Tshabalala-Msimang‚ but was never taken to parliament to be debated or passed.

It is likely that if the state is given leave to appeal that Stransham-Ford could lose his right to die with the help of a doctor if he does not choose to die this weekend.

Mhaga complained that the order allowed Stransham-Ford to approach a doctor on Thursday and die over the weekend before an appeal could be lodged.

Dignity SA's Willem Landman praised the ruling as precedent setting.