Sars does about-turn, will now welcome back two employees axed in 2017

22nd November 2022 By: News24Wire

Sars does about-turn, will now welcome back two employees axed in 2017

Sars Commissioner Edward Kieswetter

The South African Revenue Service (Sars) has dropped its opposition to the reinstatement of two staff members axed in 2017 for refusing to partake in the company's restructuring.

Former employees Hope Mashilo and Tshebeletso Seremane have been asked to return to the tax agency "at their earliest availability", roughly five years after they were dismissed.

The decision comes ten days after Sars publicly apologised and paid compensation to a dozen former staff members hounded out the the agency during the era of State capture. 

'Devastating impact'

Sars axed Mashilo and Seremane in 2017 for refusing to move to vaguely defined new jobs called "domain specialists" established as part of a controversial restructuring proposed by consultancy Bain.

Sars Commissioner Edward Kieswetter acknowledged this week that the agency's actions five years ago had a "devastating and profound impact on the lives of Ms Mashilo and Ms Seremane and their families". 

"Sars deeply regrets the hurt, pain and suffering visited on them and their families," he said. 

"I sincerely hope that with the conclusion of this process, the affected individuals and their families may experience a sense of closure and continue their own journey to healing and restoration."

The decision to reinstate Mashilo and Seremane is an about-turn for Sars, which previously argued in court that Mashilo and Seremane should not be reinstated.

But the Johannesburg Labour Court twice found in favour of the two former employees.

In late October, the court dismissed Sars's application for leave to appeal an earlier ruling ordering that Mashilo and Seremane be immediately reinstated. 

Acting Labour Court Judge Smanga Sethene ruled that Sars provided "no compelling grounds" for why they shouldn't return, describing parts of Sars's appeal bid as "startling and comical".

Kieswetter, meanwhile, denied that the agency's past opposition to the reinstatement of the two employees meant he supported the actions taken by his predecessor, Tom Moyane

"Some commentators read into my caution that I was defending Mr Moyane, the erstwhile commissioner, thus reinforcing the effects of Sars capture," he said.  

"As I have often stated before, I am beholden to nobody. I defend the institution and not the individuals who captured it. Sars and I will continue to do so and execute the Sars mandate without fear, prejudice and bias."