"JUSTICE FOR ALL"
MISSION
The mission of the new Department has been revisited and is now directed at the following aims:
1. ROLE OF THE DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE
Our challenge is to create a society in which everyone feels safe and secure in their homes, schools, places of employment and worship, sports fields, shopping complexes, places of recreation and particularly when using public transport. During the period under review, a great deal has been accomplished in this regard as well as towards effecting far reaching changes to the Department of Justice and the administration of justice as a whole, to make it representative, legitimate, just, transparent, accessible and accountable. A lot still needs to be done to instill and maintain public confidence in the administration of justice and to dispel the notion that the courts have not been effective in the fight against crime - particularly serious crime and crimes against women and children. The Department of Justice has therefore initiated a number of important steps to ensure that the courts play an effective and efficient role in the fight against crime, that they serve to deter criminals and help to combat criminality in general. However, problems still exist - for example, bail remains a matter of serious concern and adequate sentencing policies need to be devised. These and other measures to ensure that the Department of Justice plays a meaningful role in the fight against crime, will receive further attention this year.
The steps taken, progress made or achievements in this regard and in the various spheres of activities, amid a shortage of posts, human resources and budgetary constraints, are dealt with in the main document in some detail, so that the past 1000 days can be properly evaluated.
The Justice Department is responsible for the day-to-day running of the court system, and performs these functions in conjunction with the various Magistrates, Judges, and Attorneys-General, who are independent. However, the Justice Department's responsibilities extend far broader than only criminal justice, to include the production of legislation, the establishment of institutions required by the Constitution - such as the Truth and Reconciliation Commission - and the administration of the system of civil justice.
2. COMBATTING CRIME
In respect of crime, it is the responsibility of the Justice Department to ensure that adequate resources are provided to the criminal court system, and that it works fairly and efficiently. The issue of crime received urgent attention and in this regard several initiatives have been taken, both on a national and international level. This is dealt with in detail in the main document, but it can be stated that our aims in this regard is to tighten-up measures in order to protect the community effectively and to help regulate disputes and problems in all communities, in such a way as to demonstrate clearly to all South Africans: "You need no longer take the law into your own hands! You need no longer resort to violence to solve your problems! There are mechanisms and there are procedures which will help to ensure justice and peace throughout the land". This is not only in the interests of justice, but important to instil confidence in the courts.
FOR THE FIRST TIME IN OUR COUNTRY'S HISTORY, A COMPREHENSIVE NATIONAL CRIME PREVENTION STRATEGY (NCPS) HAS BEEN FORMULATED AND PUT IN PLACE TO MEET THESE CHALLENGES HEAD-ON. THIS STRATEGY HAS AS AIM TO EMPOWER THE GOVERNMENT TO DEAL WITH CRIME IN AN EFFICIENT AND MULTI-SECTORAL MANNER.
The NCPS, in which the Department is an active participant, now also makes it possible for much closer co-operation between all the relevant departments that deal with crime. Cross-cutting exercises in this regard is being considered and dealt with for greater efficiency and for closer collaboration and communication between the respective departments and also within the departments concerned. Various business plans were drafted in order to source money from the RDP funds so that the criminal justice system could be made more effective.
The combatting of crime, including crime of an organised transnational nature (which emphasises our new role in the international sphere) and the combatting of corruption have been high on the Justice Department's list of priorities, as is confirmed by the Department's 1996 legislative programme, especially the legislation that was submitted to Parliament for consideration towards the end of the session, which has a bearing on the National Crime Prevention Strategy.
Other aspects include:
a. The criminal jurisdiction of the lower courts will be increased (that is, from I year to a maximum of 3 years in the district courts and from 10 to 15 years in the regional courts) by the Judicial Matters Amendment Bill which will be promoted during the 1997 session of Parliament.
b. The system of lay assessors is being extended. Possible legislation in this regard is being considered.
c. Approximately 188 persons (witnesses and members of their families) are being protected under the Witness Protection Programme (WPP) at present. On 28 March 1996 the Minister of Justice approved the establishment of a National Witness Protection Directorate. This directorate will be established in terms of substantive legislation. As an interim measure, section 185A of the Criminal Procedure Act, 1977 and the related regulations will be amended to address problems faced by the WPP. A business plan relating to witness protection was approved by the NCPS structures and it will be implemented as soon as possible.
d. The creation of a separate juvenile justice system was referred to the South African Law Commission for investigation.
SENTENCING
a. The South African Law Commission is also, inter alia, investigating sentencing which also includes the compensation of victims, guidelines with regard to sentence and community involvement in sentencing. This investigation will address effective sentencing. Provision for minimum sentences in respect of certain offences, for example, gang and drug-related offences as well as the development of a national sentencing policy is also under consideration.
b. The Department has also recently been instructed to include provisions in a Bill, obliging presiding officers to impose compulsory minimum sentences in respect of certain serious offences. These draft provisions have been approved by Cabinet in principle. These provisions have been submitted to various role players, including the Law Commission. The Law Commission's Project Committee which is considering the whole question surrounding sentencing, including the compensation of victims, guidelines with regard to sentences and community involvement in sentencing, have considered these draft provisions, and has indicated that they would like to furnish input thereanent. After all input/comment have been received the matter will be further considered, and Cabinet again be approached to consider the matter. Thereafter the Bill will be promoted in Parliament.
BAIL
a. In depth amendments were affected to the legislation dealing with bail from 21 September 1995 to strengthen the hand of a court to refuse bail where necessary and to provide for more effective prevention of interference with state witnesses. The grounds for cancelling bail were also extended (eg. where an accused poses serious threat to the safety of the public or a particular person). Discussions were in addition held with the attorneys-general and the magistracy relating to bail aspects. It have been stressed that bail should be seriously opposed and refused in deserving cases to protect the interests of the a community. The training of court officials in this regard have furthermore received attention. In relation to bail it is also envisaged that guidelines-will be sent to each Magistrates' Office and all prosecutors so that all the relevant bail provisions are known and everyone is kept up to date with amendments relating to bail. The co-operation and full participation of the community is, however, essential. People should assist the courts in providing evidence to help bring culprits to book and in the opposing of bail.
My view is that courts should be compelled to refuse bail in appropriate cases, and legislation is being considered in this direction; at the same time consideration will be given to constitutional implications. These provisions relating to sentencing as well as those tightening-up the granting of bail, have as aim the strengthening of the hands of Government and the courts in protecting our communities against serious crime and will augment the measures contained in the NCPS.
b. Actions specifically related to national priority crimes such as corruption and white collar crime, drug trafficking and organised crime, as well as the creation of a more effective court management system, and the giving of additional training for magistrates, prosecutors and other justice personnel also received attention and are comprehensively dealt with in the main document.
c. The Department is furthermore part of the Road Traffic Safety Board, which had its first meeting on 31 January 1997, and will assist in promoting cooperation between all the relevant role players, including NGO's. A business plan has been drafted to help combat the road carnage.
3. VIOLENCE AGAINST WOMEN AND CHILDREN
Because of the profoundly negative impact on the empowerment and rights of women and children which rape and domestic violence causes, several initiatives have been implemented by the Department in this regard, as can be seen in the main document.
Mention can, however, be made of the Campaign on No Violence Against Women that the Department has launched. The objective hereof is to raise awareness and educate the community about the problem of violence against women, and receive input from civil society. This input will be presented to the Law Commission with a view to draft legislation which is responsive to the needs of the community. We support the network against violence and wishes to build cooperation with civil society in this regard.
In addition, we are looking at the following aspects:
1. Adequacy of the law - we are revisiting the legal provisions and will, eg. again look at the definition of rape; all input received will be considered and referred to the Law Commission.
2. Prosecutions - we are addressing this and aim at making prosecutions and court management of cases more effective and efficient effective. Training and sensitizing of personnel involved in these issues are also receiving attention.
3. Special courts - There appears to be greater demand for such courts. Despite the attitude of most Attorneys-general against the implementation of such courts, I urge all Heads of Offices and Attorneys- General, to make provision for such courts, wherever possible and especially in the major urban areas.
4. Treatment with compassion - we have embarked on the road to ensure that all women and child victims are treated with compassion in the courts, and training in this regard is envisaged.
4. VICTIM SUPPORT
Various aspects are being dealt with in this regard by the Department, such as making the justice system more user-friendly, witness protection, sensitising of court personnel in relation to cases involving vulnerable groups such as women and children, making courts accessible to child witnesses, special measures relating to rape cases, etc.
What can be highlighted, however, is a new investigation by the S A Law Commission. The following provisional recommendations by the Law Commission's Project committee will be considered by the working committee of the Commission shortly, followed thereafter by the publication of an issue paper for comment. It is proposed that:
a. A Victim's Advisory Council or an office for a Victims of Crime Coordinator be established through legislation to address the plight of victims.
b. Legislation should provide for a number of principles which should govern the treatment of victims. The following principles are proposed:
4. THE NEW DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE
The administration of justice is a function of the National Government and as such-does not fall within the functional areas of the provincial legislatures. In terms of the Constitution the eleven former Departments of Justice were amalgamated with effect from 1 October 1994. As a result, the new Department of Justice now consists of a personnel complement of approximately 13 902 persons (as on 9 January 1997) who are utilized in approximately 540 sub-offices, in approximately 610 buildings throughout the country. The Head Office is in Pretoria and Regional Offices are to be established in all the Provinces, in order to rationalise and-decentralise the functions of the Department as effectively as possible.
BUDGET
The budget of the Department amounts to R1 488 694 million for the 1996/97 financial year which represents 0,84% of the total State budget.
When deducting the transfer amounts - which is appropriated on the budget of the Department, but is expended by other agencies such as the Human Rights Commission, Truth and Reconciliation Commission and the Legal Aid Board which amounts to R108 823 million, the budget of the Department represents 0,78% of the total State budget. The Department received an allocation of R1 697 396 million in respect of the 1997198 financial year, which represents an increase of 6,85% on the 1996/97 financial year. When taking into account the increase related to allocations to the Truth Commission, funds required for the establishment of the National Director of Public Prosecutions, and the increase in the salaries of magistrates and the Public Protector, the Department will experience a negative growth of minus 2% in the 1997/98 financial year. Taking into account normal annual cost and tariff increases, the Department will experience an even bigger negative growth in real terms for the 1997/98 financial year.
TRANSFORMATION
BLACK WHITE COLOURED INDIAN TOTAL M F M F M F M F M F 4391 2689 2449 3423 299 293 134 224 7273 6629 %: 31.619,3 17,6 24,6 2,1 2,1 0,96 1,61 52,3 47,6
With regard to the Management Echelon, the present position is as follows:
BLACK WHITE COLOURED INDIAN TOTAL M F M F M F M F M F 24 0 16 1 1 0 0 0 41 1 %: 57,1 0 28,1 2,4 2,4 0 0 0 97,6 2,4
A new management plan for the Department has been finalized and we are at present in the process of filling the vacancies in the new management structure. This process will be concluded within the next few months and interviews for the Deputy Director Generals have already been concluded. The functions of these new Deputy Director Generals will be the following: Legislation Research, Legal Services, Corporate Services, Human Resources and Regional Co-ordination.
o Magistrates reflect the following situation:
Black males - 413; black females - 59; white males - 669; white fempales - 189; coloured males - 25; coloured females - 5; indian males - 15; indian females 12 (total 1387).
o Regional Court Magistrates reflect the following situation:
Black males - 17; black females - 0; white males - 164; white females - 7; coloured males - 1; coloured females - 0; indian males - 1; indian females - 4 (total 194).
o Since April 1994, 22 persons representative of communities other than white, have been appointed as permanent judges. This includes the appointment of the Honourable Chief Justice, Mr Justice Mahomed. In addition, various chief magistrates, regional court magistrates, regional court presidents and senior magistrates representing other communities, have been appointed. Some examples in this regard are Mr M C Bashe, Chief Magistrate Johannesburg, Mr D S F Kondile, Chief Magistrate Port Elizabeth, Mr T J Raulinga, Chief Magistrate Bloemfontein, Mr M I Mkize, Chief Magistrate Durban, Mr M S Radise, Chief Magistrate Odi, and Mr A V M Lugaju, Regional Court President Cape Town.
5.LEGISLATIVE PROGRAMME
The Department is currently responsible for the administration of about 165 Acts which cover virtually every facet of the administration of justice, including matters connected with human rights, the different adjudication structures, the law of persons and family, admiralty law criminal law and criminal procedure, law of succession, the combatting and prevention of violence, the administration of estates, legal practitioners, investigative bodies and many more. This, for example, shows an increase of 27% on the number of Acts administered in 1991. In addition to the fact that the Department was required to draft a number of Acts which emanated directly from the Constitution, it also had to ensure the drafting of new legislation, as well as the amendment of existing legislation, to conform with the changing views and sentiments of an ever changing society. The new constitutional dispensation moreover requires a revision of all existing legislation which is administered by the Department in order to bring it in line with the provisions of the Constitution, and more specifically, the provisions of the Bill of Fundamental Rights.
The legislative programme since 1994 is set out in detail in the main document, and particular reference is made to the legislative measures that were promoted to help combat crime.
THE 1997 LEGISLATIVE PROGRAMME:
The following Bills have already been introduced into Parliament or are expected to be introduced early in the 1997-Parliamentary Session and promoted during the course of the 1997 Parliamentary Session:
a. Magistrates' Courts Amendment Bill, 1996 b. Prescribed Rate of Interest Amendment Bill, 1996 c. The Abolition of Corporal Punishment Bill, 1997 d. Criminal Law Amendment Bill, 1997 e. Powers of Natural Fathers of Extra-marital Children Bill, 1997 f. Divorce Courts Amendment Bill, 1997 g. Judicial Matters Amendment Bill, 1997
The following legislation is also already receiving attention and will form part of the Department's 1997-legislative programme:
a. Rationalization of Legal Practitioners Bill, 1997. b. Judges' Remuneration and Conditions of Employment Amendment Bill, 1997 c. Debt-Collectors Bill, 1997 d. Sheriffs Amendment Bill, 1997 e. Legal Aid Amendment Bill, 1997 f. National Prosecuting Authority Bill, 1997 g. Assessors Bill, 1997 h. Witness Protection Programme Bill, 1997 i. Establishment of Family Courts Bill, 1997 j. Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination Bill, 1997 k. Convention against Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment Bill, 1997 l. The Prevention of Crime Fund Bill, 1997 m. Maintenance Amendment Bill, 1997 n. Criminal Procedure Amendment Bill, 1997 o. Unification of Legal Qualifications Bill, 1997 p. Rationalisation of Courts Bill, 1997 q. Judicial Service Commission Amendment Bill, 1997 r. Human Rights Commission Amendment Bill, 1997 s. Other possible proposed legislation which is receiving attention includes Bills to further regulate the division of pension benefits on divorce, to address a jurisdictional lacuna in the Supreme Court Act, 1959 (Act 59 of 1959), to regulate the review powers of courts in respect of administrative acts, to regulate the declaration and detention of persons as State patients in terms of the Criminal Procedure Act, 1977, and the release of such person in terms of the Mental Health Act, 1973 (Act 18 of 1973), to regulate access to minor children by interested persons and to rationalise the legislation of the former RSA and territories which was not rationalised in 1996.
THE IMPACT OF THE NEW CONSTITUTION ON THE DEPARTMENT is also dealt with in the main document.
6. HUMAN RESOURCE DEVELOPMENT
It is generally acknowledged that the rationalization of the Department brought along new demands in the field of training. The Department consequently identified human resources development as a critical component Of its strategic planning. Interventions aimed at human resources development are specifically reflected in two of the six strategic areas of importance in the "Vision 2000" draft strategic plan. Training and human resource development is furthermore considered so important that it has been identified as part of the Premier projects proposals. Particular projects and further detail in this regard is contained in the main document. Justice College's role is also highlighted there.
What can be highlighted in relation to training, is the valuable assistance we are receiving from foreign instances. For example, the Canada South Africa Justice Linkage Project was launched recently, in terms of which the Canadian Government will donate $5 million Canadian towards the training of judicial officers over a period of four years. The necessary Memorandum of Understanding was signed on 19 September 1996 and an infrastructure for the implementation of the project is soon expected to be in place. This will assist in decentralising training and also in involving civil society, including NGO's in training initiatives. Similarly we are receiving assistance from the United States of America, Australia, France and others. For this the Department is very appreciative.
7. THE WORK OF THE SOUTH AFRICAN LAW COMMISSION have been significant in our transformation process and is therefore focussed in some detail on in the main document. The main policy embraced by the new restructured Law Commission is that emphasis should be placed on the fact that the Commission is a community orientated institution and that it should be seen by members of the public as a body that is subservient to the needs of the community. It is therefore imperative that the community should become involved in the Commission's activities at grassroots level and that the Commission should not be viewed by the public as an academic and aloof institution. Their PLANNING FOR 1997 includes aspects relating to Maintenance, Family Violence, Juvenile Justice, Sexual Offences against children, Recognition of customary marriages, Islamic personal law, Simplification of Criminal Procedure, and Sentencing.
8. GENERAL ASPECTS
The main document also gives full detail relating to aspects such as:
What can also be pointed out in this regard, is that the Accommodation Section of the Department has embarked on the formulation of an extensive and detailed Business Plan in which all accommodation requirements at those centres as identified to be in dire need of revamping on a major scale, were listed and duly promoted with the RDP office for possible financial assistance. The Business Plan comprises a listing of 96 services pertaining especially to those centres in the former self-governing territories and TBVC states and range from repair and renovation services as well as the provision of additional accommodation, to the erection of complete new court structures. The appropriation of funds for these services is receiving attention. The prime object of the Business Plan is the eventual and practical provisioning of judicial services in all of the nine provinces, to all communities where the administration of justice and it's related functions are urgently needed. The re-vamping process entails a number of services which, cumulatively, serve to bolster proper application of the maxim "justice for all".
Due to ongoing neglect and a constant non-availability of adequate funds, the general condition of most rnagistrate's courts has regressed appallingly and funds will be well applied in the eventual repair and renovation thereof.
9. CONCLUDING REMARKS
Please refer to the main document in this regard. However, in general the following can be highlighted:
As can be seen from the above, and the enormous work already done, in the short period since April 1994, the transformation and the democratisation of the legal system and its institutions in particular are well under way.
Issued by the Ministry of Justice, 13 February 1997