Department of Transport




Draft Administrative Adjudication of Road Traffic Offences Bill, 1998




26 April 1998

Revised Draft

GENERAL NOTICE NO. ............ OF 1998

DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORT

DRAFT ADMINISTRATIVE ADJUDICATION OF ROAD TRAFFIC OFFENCES BILL, 1998

The above-mentioned Draft Bill is published in the Schedule for comment .
Interested parties are invited to submit written comments no later than 22 June 1998 to:

Ms D. Briesch (Law Advisor)
Department of Transport
Forum Building (Room 4109)
Private Bag x 193
PRETORIA
0001
Fax No: (012) 328 5102

The Draft Bill is explained in the Backgrounder preceding the attached Draft Bill.


Contents

Schedule

Chapter I
Interpertation of Act

Chapter II
Road Traffic Infringement Agency

Chapter III
Adjudication Procedure

Chapter IV
Points Demerit System

Chapter V
General Matters



SCHEDULE

DRAFT ADMINISTRATIVE ADJUDICATION OF ROAD TRAFFIC OFFENCES BILL, 1998

BACKGROUNDER

The main aims of the Act are to:

2. Based on a preliminary survey, it is anticipated that in the region of 90% of traffic offences for which notices or summonses are currently issued in terms of the Criminal Procedure Act, 1977 (Act No. 51 of 1977), will fall in the ambit of the Act. Of these, a large percentage will, in turn, be dealt with as infringements, leaving a small portion of traffic offences likely to end up in court. This will ensure that the resources of the courts and the prosecuting authority are freed to deal with the most serious offences, hopefully resulting in higher conviction rates and the imposition of sentences with a greater deterrent value.

The main features of the Act are dealt with in further detail below.

ROAD TRAFFIC INFRINGEMENT AGENCY

4.1 The agency is established at national level at arms length from government, subject to the joint oversight of the Ministers of Transport and Justice. It will perform certain quasi-judicial, as well as execution and prosecution support functions. Examples of these are:

4.2 As the agency will be performing certain quasi-judicial functions, it will be headed by a registrar who has a thorough understanding and experience of cross-functional business management and motivational leadership. The registrar will be assisted by 3(or more) deputy registrars. Deputy registrars will be responsible for:

4.3 The agency personnel will also comprise a component of representations officers. Representations officers will be road traffic specialists who are legally-qualified or have experience in road traffic management. These officers will be the first port of call for persons on whom infringement notices have been served in so far as they will consider representations where persons feel there are reasonable grounds why they would not be held liable by a court. These officers will play an important role in filtering the majority of cases by ensuring that most cases are settled administratively rather than by the courts. On the one hand, these officers will ensure that where representations have merit, the matter is not pursued and notices are cancelled. If representations are rejected, officers will fully explain their reasons to infringers in writing. This will ensure that infringers can make informed decisions whether their cases have any merit and whether it is worthwhile to insist on being tried.

4.4 Representations officers will, in practice, become highly proficient in evaluating the merits of individual road traffic cases. It is, therefore, envisaged that they may also be utilized as expert witnesses to assist in the prosecution of serious offences in the courts. At the same time, they could assist in the training of prosecutors responsible for road traffic prosecutions.

4.5 It is envisaged that the agency may also appoint sheriffs to assist with its execution functions. Although sheriffs will be employees of the agency they will in all other respects comply with the Sheriffs Act, 1986. Sheriffs will execute their function in terms of the rules promulgated in the Magistrates' Courts Act, 1944.

4.6 The efficient functioning of the agency will largely depend on an appropriate information management system. In practice, the agency will be handling large volumes of transactions emanating from traffic authorities throughout the country. At the same time, the agency will deal directly with infringers during various stages of the administrative process. This will require an appropriate database and the necessary links to the National Traffic Information System. Finally, the agency will be dealing with the courts by referring for trial those cases in which infringers have opted to be tried.

4.7 The agency will be funded mainly from fees for collecting penalties and by charging infringers for the issuing of courtesy letters, enforcement orders and warrants. In practice, a huge volume of transactions are likely to be handled. This will require an appropriate financial management system to process transactions and account for monies received and disbursed. In line with the existing practise, penalties paid to the issuing authorities are retained by these authorities.

4.8 The agency will be represented by a board comprising of an Attorney-General, the chairperson of the Magistrates' Commission, three persons representative of the private sector appointed on account of their commercial expertise and the registrar. The function of the board will be to strengthen co-operation between these authorities, to monitor the activities of the agency, advise on ways to improve its effectiveness and identify areas where the agency may assist the law enforcement and adjudication process.

5. PROCEDURE

5.1 The main features of the procedure to be implemented by the agency are:

5.2 The administrative procedure is supported by a number of additional mechanisms:

5.3 The bill also introduces a points demerit system which applies to drivers, professional drivers and operators of motor vehicles. Infringers will occur prescribed demerit points which will result in the suspension of a driving licence, professional driving permit or operator card once the prescribed threshold is exceeded (points will, similarly, also be incurred upon conviction by a court). In the event that a person incurs a third suspension, this will result in the cancellation of the licence, permit or card as the case may be. During the period of suspension, a person is prohibited from driving or operating a motor vehicle.

BILL

To promote road traffic quality by providing for a scheme to discourage road traffic contraventions, to facilitate the adjudication of road traffic infringements, to support the prosecution of offences in terms of the national and provincial laws relating to road traffic, and implement a points demerit system; to provide for the establishment of an agency to administer the scheme; to provide for the establishment of a board to represent the agency; and to provide for matters connected therewith.

BE IT ENACTED by the Parliament of the Republic of South Africa, as follows: -


CHAPTER I

Interpretation of Act

Definitions

1. In this Act, unless the context otherwise indicates -

"acceptable identification" means -

"agency" means the Road Traffic Infringement Agency established by section 3;

"authorised officer" means -

"board" means the board of the agency established by section 6;

"courtesy letter" means a courtesy letter contemplated in section 20;

"date of service" means the date on which an infringer has signed for the relevant document served on him or her under section 31;

"demerit points" means demerit points contemplated in section 25;

"Director-General" means the Director-General of the Department of Transport;

"disqualification period" means the period contemplated in section 26 during which a person is disqualified from driving or operating a motor vehicle;

"enforcement order" means an enforcement order contemplated in section 21;

"infringement" means a major or a minor infringement;

"infringement notice" means an infringement notice contemplated in section 17;

"infringer" means a person who allegedly committed an infringement;

"issuing authority" means -

in so far as such authority or administration is responsible for traffic matters in its area of jurisdiction;

"major infringement" means an offence prescribed as a major infringement under section 30(a);

"MEC" means a member of an Executive Council appointed in terms of section 132 of the Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996 (Act No. 108 of 1996), and who is responsible for road traffic matters;

"Minister" means the Minister of Transport acting with the concurrence of the Minister of Justice;

"minor infringement" means an offence prescribed as a minor infringement under section 30(a);

"national contraventions register" means the National Traffic Information System on which the offence details of every individual are recorded in terms of this Act;

"offence" means an offence prescribed under section 30(a) ;

"penalty" means the administrative penalty payable for an infringement as contemplated in section 32;

"prescribed" means prescribed by regulation by the Minister under section 34;

"this Act" includes any notice or regulation made under it.

Objects of Act

2. The objects of this Act, are despite the Criminal Procedure Act, 1977 (Act No. 51 of 1977), to -


Chapter II

Road Traffic Infringement Agency

Establishment of agency

3. (1) An agency, known as the Road Traffic Infringement Agency, is hereby established as a statutory authority responsible to the Minister.

(3) The agency must establish one central office, and may establish sub-offices at provincial or municipal level.

Functions of agency

4. (1) The functions of the agency are, despite the Criminal Procedure Act, 1977 (Act No. 51 of 1977), to -

(3) The agency undertakes its functions in terms of subsection (1)(b) by -

(4) The agency undertakes its functions in terms of subsection (1)(c) by -

(5) The agency undertakes its functions in terms of subsection (1)(d) by -

(6) The agency must, in order to properly execute its functions, establish the prescribed information management system and database which is connected with the national contraventions register, and utilise such database to create, process and maintain records with regard to any action performed by it in terms of this Act.

Sub-contracting

5. (1) The agency may, subject to the business plan approved by the board, appoint agents, or contract with any person, to perform any function vested in it in terms of this Act or any other law.

(2) Similar procedures as those laid down in the State Tender Board Act, 1968 (Act No. 86 of 1968), must be followed in respect of any contract contemplated in subsection (1), but the State Tender Board may not be involved.

Establishment of board

6. (1) A board to represent and control the agency is hereby established, comprising -

(2) The members of the board contemplated in subsection (1)(a) must serve for a period determined by the Minister, whereafter they may be re-appointed.

(3) The meetings of the board are chaired by the member designated by the Minister.

(4) The board meets at least twice per year or as often as may be required.

(5) The board may determine its own procedures for meetings and decisions.

(6) Members of the board who are not in the full-time employment of the State may be paid such remuneration and allowances as may be determined by the Minister with the concurrence of the Minister of Finance.

Role of board

7. (1) The role of the board is to -

(2) The board may assign any of its functions to any employee of the agency, or a member of the board, whom the board deems fit to perform the function.

(3) The board must annually submit a report on the activities of the agency to the Minister for tabling in Parliament.

Appointment of registrar

8. (1)The members of the board referred to in section 6(1)(a), (b) and(c) must appoint a person with proven expertise in corporate and financial management as the registrar of the agency.

(2) The registrar oversees the functions of the agency in accordance with a business plan prepared by the registrar and approved by the board, and in particular the -

(3) The registrar may, in writing, assign a function contemplated in subsection (2) to a deputy registrar or registrars.

(4) The registrar must annually submit a report concerning the activities and operations of the agency to the board.

Appointment of deputy registrars

9. (1) The board may appoint such persons as deputy registrars as may be necessary.

(2) No person may be appointed as a deputy registrar unless that person has -

Appointment of representations officers

10. (1) The registrar may, subject to the business plan approved by the board, appoint such persons as representations officers as may be necessary.

(2) No person may be appointed as a representations officer unless that

person -

Appointment of sheriffs

11. (1) The registrar may, subject to the business plan approved by the board, appoint such persons as sheriffs or deputy sheriffs as may be necessary.

(2) The provisions of the Sheriffs Act, 1986 (Act No. 90 of 1986), apply, with the necessary changes, to a sheriff appointed under subsection (1).

Administrative staff, and remuneration

12. (1) The registrar must, subject to the business plan approved by the board, establish the administration of the agency and may appoint such administrative staff members as may be necessary.

(2) The agency may pay to the persons in its employ such remuneration and allowances, and may provide them with such pensions and other benefits, as the board may determine with the approval of the Minister granted with the concurrence of the Minister of Finance.

Financing of agency

13. (1) The agency finances its operating and capital costs from -

(2) The agency must utilise any money contemplated in subsection (1) in accordance with the statement of estimated expenditure referred to in subsection (3).

(3) The registrar -

(4) The financial year of the agency is determined by the Minister.

(5) At the end of each financial year the registrar must invest any surplus funds of the agency in a separate account, from which payments may be made to any authority or body for the purpose of road safety or law enforcement.

Bookkeeping and auditing

14. (1) The agency must, in accordance with generally accepted accounting practice, keep such accounting and related records as are necessary to represent fairly the state of affairs and business of the agency and to explain its transactions and financial position.

(2) The registrar is the accounting officer of the agency and charged with the responsibility of accounting for all monies received and payments made by the agency.

(3) The accounting and related records of the agency must be audited annually by an auditor registered in terms of section 15 of the Public Accountants' and Auditors' Act, 1991 (Act No. 80 of 1991).

Banking account

15. The agency may, with the approval of the Director-General, open and maintain one or more accounts with a bank registered finally as a bank in terms of the Banks Act, 1990 (Act No. 94 of 1990), in which must be deposited the money received by the agency and from which payments by it or on its behalf may be made.

Limitation of liability

16. No employee of the agency nor the agency is liable by reason of any act done in good faith by such employee in terms of this Act.


CHAPTER III

Adjudication procedure

Infringement notice

17. (1) If a person is alleged to have committed an infringement, an authorised officer or a person duly authorised by an issuing authority, must in stead of a notice contemplated in section 56 or 341 of the Criminal Procedure Act, 1977 (Act No. 51 of 1977), serve or cause to be served on that infringer an infringement notice, which must -

failing which the matter will be referred to the agency and a courtesy letter will be issued in terms of section 20, whereafter the infringer becomes liable to pay both the penalty and the prescribed fee of the courtesy letter.

(2) If an infringer fails to comply with an infringement notice within the period contemplated in subsection (1), the issuing authority must give notice of it, in the prescribed manner, to the agency for further action in terms of section 20.

Compliance with infringement notice

18. (1) If an infringer complies with an infringement notice by paying the penalty, as reduced by the discount contemplated in section 17(1)(d), the issuing authority must -

(2) If the infringer elects to be tried in court, the issuing authority must -

(3) If the infringer satisfies the issuing authority that he or she was not the driver of the motor vehicle as contemplated in section 17(1)(g)(iv), the issuing authority must cancel the infringement notice, and may serve or cause to be served on the person identified as the driver an infringement notice in relation to the alleged infringement.

Representations

19. (1) An infringer who has been served with an infringement notice alleging that he or she has committed a minor infringement, may make representations with respect to that notice to the agency.

(2) Representations under subsection (1) are made by submitting a sworn statement to the agency in the prescribed manner, indicating the existence of reasonable grounds why he or she should not be held liable for the penalty payable in terms of the infringement notice.

(3) No representations are valid unless the sworn statement referred to in subsection (2) is submitted not later than the 28 days specified in section

17(1) (g).

(5) A representations officer must duly consider the representations and any reply thereto, may conduct independent investigations to verify the facts and may -

(6) If the representations are allowed the agency must forthwith cancel the infringement notice, and inform the infringer in the prescribed manner of the decision.

(7) If the representations are rejected, the representations officer may advise the infringer to go to court, and must serve or cause to be served on the infringer a written notification informing him or her -

(8) If an infringer pays the specified penalty as contemplated in subsection (7)(b), the agency must -

Courtesy letter

20. (1) If an infringer has failed to comply with an infringement notice as contemplated in section 17(1)(f) and the agency has been notified of it in terms of section 17(2), the agency must issue a courtesy letter and serve it on the infringer.

(2) A courtesy letter must -

(3) If an infringer pays the penalty and fee as contemplated in subsection (2)(b), the agency must -

(4) If an infringer notifies the agency that he or she wishes to be tried in court, the agency must -

Enforcement orders

21. (1) If an infringer fails to comply with the requirements of a notification contemplated in section 19(7) or a courtesy letter contemplated in section 20(2)(b), as the case may be, the registrar must, subject to subsection (2) -

(2) No enforcement order is issued, unless the registrar is satisfied that -

(3) An enforcement order must -

(4) If an infringer pays the specified penalty and fees as contemplated in subsection (3)(a), the agency must update the national contraventions register in the prescribed manner.

(5) Subject to subsection (6), no -

may be issued to an infringer or in respect of a motor vehicle registered in the name of an infringer, if an enforcement order has been issued in respect of such infringer.

(6) The provisions of subsection (5) do not apply in respect of an infringer who provides proof in the prescribed manner that he or she has in the meantime paid the penalty and fees specified in the enforcement order.

(7) An infringer on whom an enforcement order has been served may comply with it by paying the specified penalty and fees to -

(8) A registering authority or driving licence testing centre must notify the agency in the prescribed manner if it has received any payment contemplated in subsection (7) and must pay over such payment to the agency after reduction of the prescribed collection fee.

(9) An enforcement order must be revoked by the registrar if -

(10) If an infringer has elected to be tried for an infringement in terms of this Act, and the infringer has failed to appear for trial, the clerk of the court must, subject to the Criminal Procedure Act, 1977 (Act No. 51 of 1977), notify the agency of such failure, and the registrar must proceed to issue an enforcement order against the infringer in terms of subsection (1).

Warrants

22. (1) If an infringer on whom an enforcement order is served does not comply with the provisions of the order contemplated in section 21(3)(a), the registrar may issue a warrant against the infringer and update the national contraventions register, and may report the infringer to a credit bureau.

(2) Sections 66, 67 and 68 of the Magistrates' Courts Act, 1944 (Act No. 32 of 1944), apply with the necessary changes to a warrant issued in terms of this section, and in such application the infringer is deemed to be the judgement debtor.

(3) A warrant must be executed by a sheriff, appointed under section 11, in the manner prescribed in rules 41 and 42 of the rules of Court promulgated in terms of the Magistrates' Courts Act, 1944.

(4) If a warrant has been executed, the registrar must record the payment of the penalty and fees from the proceeds of the execution on the national contraventions register.

(5) If the execution of a warrant produces no property to seize and sell, the agency must, subject to section 32(2) -

Non-prosecution

23. (1) An issuing authority may, at any time after an enforcement order has been issued, apply in writing to the registrar not to refer a case of an alleged infringement to the court.

(2) If an application is made not to refer a case to court, the registrar must -

(3) Despite any other law, an infringer who has been dealt with administratively in terms of this Chapter may not be prosecuted again on the same facts.

Trial

24. Once the agency has referred a matter to the court in terms of section 20(4)(a) or 22(5)(a), the Criminal Procedure Act, 1977, (Act No. 51 of 1977), applies, and -


Chapter IV

Points demerit system

Points demerit system

25. (1) Any person who has committed an offence or infringement, incurs the number of demerit points prescribed under section 30(c) in accordance with subsections (2) and (3).

(2) Subject to subsection (4), demerit points are incurred on the date on which the penalty and fee, if any, imposed for the infringement are paid, an enforcement order is issued or the infringer is convicted of the offence, as the case may be.

(4) If a person appeals against a conviction by the court for an offence no demerit points are recorded unless the appeal is rejected or abandoned in the prescribed manner.

(5) A printout from the national contraventions register which is verified by the agency is on the face of it evidence of the demerit points incurred by the person, but nothing prevents a person from approaching the court on appeal or review in connection with the demerit points recorded against that person in the said register.

Prohibition on driving or operating motor vehicle

26. (1) If a person incurs demerit points which, when added to the points previously recorded against that person in the national contraventions register, exceeds the total contemplated in section 30(d), that person is disqualified from driving or operating any motor vehicle for the period referred to in subsection (2).

(3) A person who is disqualified in terms of this section -

(4) Any person who drives or operates a motor vehicle during his or her disqualification period is guilty of an offence and liable on conviction to a fine or imprisonment for a period not exceeding one year.

Notification

27. (1) A notice, as prescribed, must forthwith be sent by registered mail to a person who has incurred more than the number of demerit points referred to in section 30(d), which notice must -

(2) A notice referred to in subsection (1) must be sent by the issuing authority within whose area of jurisdiction the person in question is resident.

Surrender of driving licence, professional driving permit and operator card

28. (1) A person who incurs demerit points resulting in a disqualification in terms of section 26 to drive or operate a motor vehicle for a third time, must forthwith surrender his or her driving licence, professional driving permit or the operator card issued in respect of that motor vehicle to the issuing authority contemplated in section 27(2) for cancellation.

(2) An issuing authority must, upon receipt of a driving licence, professional driving permit or operator card, as the case may be, take the necessary steps to cancel such licence, permit or card.

(3) A person whose licence, permit or card has been cancelled in terms of this section is during his or her disqualification period also disqualified from applying for or being issued with -

(4) Upon expiry of his or her disqualification period, a person referred to in subsection (3) may re-apply for and be issued with a driving licence, professional driving permit or operator card in terms of the national road traffic laws.

Reduction of demerit points

29. If demerit points have been incurred by any person, the issuing authority contemplated in section 27(2) must reduce the total number of points recorded in the national contraventions register against that person with one point for every three months, or such other period as may be prescribed, during which no demerit points are incurred by that person, except for -

Categorisation of offences and infringements and demerit points

30. The Minister, acting with the concurrence of the MEC of each province, may for the purpose of this Act -


CHAPTER V

General Matters

Service of documents

31. Any document required to be served on an infringer in terms of this Act may be served personally or by registered mail, and it is regarded to have been served on the date the infringer has signed for the receipt of the document.

Penalties

32. (1) The penalty prescribed under section 30(b) for each infringement must, despite any other law, be imposed administratively in terms of Chapter III, subject to the discount contemplated in section 17(1)(d).

(2) The laws on prescription are not applicable to penalties, and they may be collected at any time.

Apportionment of penalties

33. Despite section 6 of the Finance and Financial Adjustments Acts Consolidation Act, 1977 (Act No. 11 of 1977), any penalty received by the agency in terms of this Act must be paid over monthly, after deduction of an amount equal to the discount contemplated in section 17(1)(d), to the issuing authority under whose authority the infringement notice was issued, and if it was not issued under the authority of such authority, to the issuing authority within whose area of jurisdiction the infringement was committed.

Regulations

34. The Minister may make regulations, which are not inconsistent with this Act, relating to any matter that may or must be prescribed in terms of this Act, including -

Transitional provisions

35. (1) Any notice issued in terms of section 56 or 341 of the Criminal Procedure Act, 1977 (Act No. 51 of 1977, before the date of commencement of section 17, may be continued and finalised under that Act, but no such notice may be issued after that date in respect of an offence.

(2) Chapter IV only applies in respect of offences or infringements committed on or after the date of commencement of that Chapter.

Short title and commencement

36. (1) This Act is called the Administrative Adjudication of Road Traffic Offences Act, 1998, and comes into operation on a date determined by the Minister by notice in the Gazette.

(2) Different dates may be determined under subsection (1) in respect of different provisions of this Act and different areas of the Republic.